
16 oz Bone-In Ribeye
$68Heavily marbled, deeply seared, finished with rosemary herb butter.



Hand-cut USDA Prime, dry-aged in our own butcher's room and finished over hickory coals. The kind of dinner you remember.
Signature Cuts

Heavily marbled, deeply seared, finished with rosemary herb butter.

Aged 28 days, dry-rubbed, hickory-grilled. Sliced tableside for two.

The most tender cut, red wine demi-glace and herb butter.

Point Reyes blue cheese, smoked bacon, buttermilk dressing.

Single-barrel bourbon, smoked demerara, hand-cut ice.

Our Story
Hickory Forge opened in 2011 inside a century-old brick butcher shop on Old Mill Road. Pitmaster James Holloway and his daughter Caroline kept the original tile floors, the hand-painted ceiling, and the same stubborn belief: that a steakhouse should feel like an occasion.
Fifteen years later, we still butcher every steak in-house, still hand-pour every Old Fashioned, and still believe a good dinner is best measured in how late you stayed.
Read our storyWhy Guests Return
Four things we obsess over — so dinner feels like an event, not an errand.
Every steak finishes over real hickory coals. It's slower. It's smokier. It's the difference you can taste from the first bite.
We hand-select the top 2% of beef — then dry-age it in our own butcher's room for 21 to 28 days. The result: deep flavor, exceptional tenderness.
200+ American whiskeys, from rare single barrels to dusty bottles you can't find anywhere else. Our bartenders pour with stories.
Warm welcomes, white napkins on your lap, a manager who knows your name. The way a steakhouse used to feel — and still should.

The bourbon bar
From rare Kentucky single barrels to small-batch ryes and dusty bottles you won't find anywhere else — our bourbon list is a love letter to American whiskey. Ask for a flight; our bartenders will guide you through it.
See the bourbon listGuest Notes
"Hickory Forge is the rare steakhouse that takes both the steak and the room seriously — a warm, room-temperature classic that makes every other night out feel rushed."
"The ribeye crust is unreal. Cooked exactly to temperature, the herb butter is doing the lord's work — easily my favorite steak in three states."
"Drove an hour for our anniversary and would do it again next month. The tomahawk for two was a moment. Service was unbelievable."
"Took my dad here for his 70th. The team comped a slice of bourbon pecan pie with a candle. Made his whole year. We'll be back."
"Filet, creamed spinach, an Old Fashioned. That's it. That's the review. Best steakhouse experience I've had outside of New York."
Reserve a booth by the fire, or call ahead for takeout — your steak will be hot and waiting.